North
Alabama, USA, Feb 7 - On 30 January, the quiet conservative city of
Huntsville was abuzz with news many residents found troubling. 100-150
'alien' workers from Nepal had "disappeared" with "thousands of
dollars" worth of "furniture" from apartments they had rented. The
workers had been hired under temporary working visas by Cinram, a
Canadian company, at the Huntsville plant. The news of their flight was
broken by WAAY-TV, a local station, saying, "The group of workers from
Nepal simply disappeared without any warning, creating a potential
security risk". The story also appeared on its website, and East of
Huntsville, a local blog, followed suit with a post titled "What's
Going On At Cinram?". The post repeats details reported by News Channel
19's Barry Hiett: "Taking not only their own belongings from their
Huntsville apartments, it appears many of them have also made off with
the furnishings provided with their apartments. By some estimates as
much
as $200,000 worth of furniture."
Largely based on the
report by Associated Press, Nepal's daily Kantipur and The Kathmandu
Post published the story on the same day. Another website, Nepali Post,
also followed with a similar report, and it didn't take long before the
national American media turned its attention toward the story. By 2
February, CNN had picked it up, when Lou Dobbs equated the Nepali flag
with "visa violation," and the ultra-conservative, infamous Rush
Limbaugh made it a talking point on his radio show.
"Our families
are really worried because they have no idea what has happened here,"
one of the Nepali workers who is still working at Cinram told us. "The
media so far hasn't done us justice. We see the landlord's claims being
broadcast, but we haven't been represented fairly."
The facts can
be clearly explained in at least two matters: first, all Nepalis
involved had been given an official document by the employment agency,
Ambassador Personnel, stating they could leave the job any time they
wanted to; the H-2B visas on which the Nepali workers came to the
United States are still valid for several more months (all of them were
validated for a minimum of seven months), and as
stated, they were under no contract to stay with the job at Cinram.
Second,
there had never been thousands of dollars worth of furniture to steal
in the first place. The apartments are operated by a company called
Total Management Services, and are furnished with old couches and beds.
The furniture consists of no more than plastic tables and chairs, the
kind that are more commonly used in the garden. Most rooms also come
with old television sets, and the landlords had promised to give the
Nepali tenants a DVD player per apartment if they paid their rents on
the first of every month. "We moved furniture around from one room to
the other, but we haven't stolen anything," said one of the workers
requesting anonymity.
One thing that is clear amongst the 40 or so Nepalis workers left, from
the original lot of about 240, is that each is now stricken with
paranoia and embarrassment. "It was very humiliating for us to go to
work when the media reported that we were thieves," said a worker. "And
now, even though we had plans to leave Cinram after some time, for
whatever reason, we were worried that we would be caught."
Another mistake in the reports that have so far come out of Huntsville
is the impression that the 100 or so Nepali workers walked out en
masse. In reality, it appears that Nepali workers had been trickling
out of Huntsville for weeks now. In fact, some never even made it here
to begin with, immediately seeking out other options after arriving in
the United States via JFK airport in New York. And this issue would
have never been publicized if not for the landlords' accusation of
theft. "I think the landlords got upset with us because they had
planned to take our rent money for seven months, but that dream got
shattered when they realized we were leaving," another young worker
from Myagdi, Nepal, said. "But the thing is, we don't want to fight
with these people, because we can't. And we don't want to start any
trouble."
The Nepali workers also claim that even after signing the lease they
weren't briefed, and none of them to this day have been given a copy.
Only after Nepalis demanded to know what the process was to leave the
apartment, they declared a month's notice was a must. However, they
also told the Nepalis that they would not be given a release form or
any document stating that they had left following due process. "Now I
have seen others-Jamaicans, Hispanics-leaving with no notice of any
kind only after a week, or even a few days of having moved in. How come
that wasn't a problem for the landlord?" asks one worker, also
requesting anonymity, fearing reprisal. "We are just so worried and
scared of what will happen to us, and how people will view Nepali
workers from now on because of the reports that accuse us of being
thieves," said another.
The fairest report yet published came today in the Sunday Edition of
The Huntsville Times. The article was written by Challen Stephens, who
with Combrian Lawson had written an article about Cinram's hiring
practices and the arrival of Nepali workers on 16 November last year
for the same paper. Today's article gives ample space to the Nepali
side of the story, explaining the right of the workers to leave any
time they wish and how many of those that have left have already found
jobs in other American cities. "We are really glad that finally someone
has explained the situation after talking to us," a relieved worker
said after carefully reading the article. "But I feel that a lot of
damage has already been done."
WAAY-TV is now hoping to meet with some of the remaining three dozen or
so Nepalis, to hear and broadcast their side of their story, four days
after the original report.
Oye Shanker, refrain from posting up peep's pics could ya?? Where is the damn source for your allegations? You're openly defaming peeps you don't even know on this forum while hiding behind that pseudonym like a lil dumbo-eared country mouse. WTF??
As Huntsville's new labor strategy makes headlines on the opposite side of the globe, the Nepalese workers who continue to pack boxes at Cinram say their missing countrymen didn't leave without an official OK.
On Nov. 29, a few weeks after the first of more than 200 guest workers from Nepal began labeling and packing DVDs at Cinram's Huntsville plant, a letter marked "Personal and Confidential" arrived at the workers' apartments.
The short form letter stated that employment was at-will of the company, adding that: "Employees are free to relinquish their positions at any time, with or without cause."
Ambassador Personnel, the temporary agency that technically employs and pays the workers on behalf of Canadian-based Cinram, sent the formal notice.
The workers from Nepal, many of them business owners in their own country, say they interpreted this as a chance to leave, many looking for higher-paying jobs elsewhere. At Cinram, they earned $8 per hour but received fewer hours than they hoped. More than 150 left.
"Why they are missing is their primary motivation is to work and earn money," said Dr. Tilak Shrestha, a Nepalese scientist here who has befriended several of the workers. "There is not enough work and they went other places to find better work than the Cinram."
"Before getting that letter, no one went other places," said one of the remaining workers, who did not wish to be identified for fear of retaliation.
Doug Wilson, the president of Ambassador, told The Times last week that the missing workers had become homesick and returned to Nepal early. Lynne Fisher, spokesperson for Cinram, said the same, adding that Cinram notified Homeland Security when the foreign workers did not report for work.
Wilson did not return calls Friday, and Fisher said she had no knowledge of the letter and no comment. As of Friday, Homeland Security had turned the matter over to Immigrations and Customs Enforcement. "We're looking into the matter," said ICE spokesman Temple Black.
Diplomatic territory
The situation in Huntsville has led to stories in newspapers in Nepal, a poor, mountainous nation separating China from India. The situation has also drawn the interest of a Nepali aid association in New York and led at least one Nepali journalist to visit Huntsville.
Huntsville has entered into diplomatic territory, said Shrestha, whether the people at Cinram realize it or not. "It is about how the United States and the U.S. government wants to deal with Third World people," he said, adding that the workers would take home lessons and opinions to share in a small, developing country. "It's like a backward Peace Corps."
Advertisement
From October through early January, Cinram used a temporary worker program known as the H-2B visa to bring 1,142 laborers to Huntsville. About 800 came from Jamaica, the rest from Nepal, Bolivia, Ukraine and the Dominican Republic.
Today, fewer than 50 of more than 200 Nepali workers remain at Cinram. At a meeting with Shrestha and five workers who remain, all said they are confused by the use of the word "missing" for their compatriots, who are permitted to travel freely within the United States under their visas.
However, contrary to corporate explanations, one of the remaining Nepali workers said only a few returned home. "Many Nepalese went to work in other places, " he said.
Ambassador had arrangements with numerous landlords across town to house the workers. Landlord Mary Snopl housed the Nepalis, and she complained to a local TV station last week that some of them had stolen furniture on their way out of town.
The workers say no one from the TV news station checked with the remaining workers before the report. "They haven't asked us anything. Just make news and go away," said one worker.
The workers say some items may have appeared missing because, when co-workers would leave, those who stayed would borrow the plastic chairs, or replace a broken TV with a working one. "None of these guys are going to run around with a plastic table and dirty pans," said Shrestha.
A walk through the apartments in November - and again on Friday - revealed plastic patio furniture, used sleeper couches, beds, small $150 TV sets and old cookware.
"If that's the case, that's great," said Snopl of the borrowed furniture, although she hadn't confirmed it.
"They're very nice, the group that we have left," she said. "We feel bad they're taking some of the heat for what some of the other people from their country did. They are hard workers, they sure would like more hours at Cinram."
Snopl also said that Ambassador ought to have better vetted the more than 20 landlords before divvying up the guest workers as they arrived.
Little overtime
Back in Nepal last fall, the workers say they never heard of Ambassador. The workers produced contracts signed in Nepal that show only Cinram and the name of a director of human resources for Cinram's Huntsville plant. The contract promises $8 per hour, $12 for overtime. "Substantial overtime is generally available," reads the contract.
However, since the end of the Christmas busy season, workers have had little overtime, working only 33 hours one week, 44 the next. Checks range between $200 to $300 on average before rent.
Of the five workers assembled on Thursday, one ran a cigarette distributorship, one worked for his national airlines, one was an electrician, another a motorcycle dealer. All speak English, as it is compulsory in school in Nepal, a nation of Hindus and Buddhists.
One worker said he paid $750 to come here. Others paid more, but would not go into details. Most plan to return to their jobs after May 31. "If Cinram was providing 40 hours a week then they would not go anywhere else," said Shrestha.
However, Santosh Pokhrel, a former Nepali journalist who runs a gas station in Madison, said some of the workers told him they paid up to $25,000 for the chance to come here.
"The honest answer is they are not going back until they make their money," said Pokhrel during a separate interview. "It's like a Mexican pays a coyote to cross the border."
Pokhrel said about 100 Nepali families live in the Huntsville area. He said he and others had spoken with some of the workers after the news surfaced this week.
According to the CIA's world factbook: "Nepal is among the poorest and least developed countries in the world with almost one-third of its population living below the poverty line."
"You can barely find a job back home," said Anand Lepcha, who works in a restaurant here. "Finding a job is big dreams."
The workers are dispersing to any city where they may know a friend or relative or have a line on work, said Pokhrel, but they aren't staying here. "They won't find anything because you have to drive a car in Huntsville."
Rush Limbaugh too was talking about it? Poor chap he has nothing to yowl......
With John McCain, one of “Gang of 12†(senators who pushed for failed Immigration Bill 2007), advancing as prez candidate from the Republican side, the ultras within the party establishment cant maneuver much....and they are highly frustrated at this moment. Otherwise, during the crucial election hour, people like Rush Limbaugh would not have spent time for some 100 foreigners, who have not been proven illegal.
HUNTSVILLE, Ala. (WAAY)
- Federal authorities are trying to track down more than 100 Cinram
workers from Nepal who went missing after their arrival in Huntsville.
Now, the company who brought the workers to the United States claim to
have located some of them.
Last week federal authorities confirmed that the employees from
Nepal who were in the country on a worker’s visa had disappeared
without a trace. No one knows where the workers went, but landlords who
were housing the Nepalese said some of them took off with television
sets, furniture, and other valuables.
Officials at Blair Staffing Agency said they have found passports with return stamps from Nepal.
The company president told WAAY-31 News that he doesn’t know for sure how many workers may have returned.
The Department of Homeland Security uses a tracking system for all
foreign workers, and officials there haven’t confirmed any of the
Nepalese actually left the country.
There is a small Nepalese community that has called Huntsville home, some for many years. Leaders of this group told WAAY-31 News Monday that they’re not happy with what the national attention has done to their reputation.
“It’s pretty embarassing to us, even though no one else is accusing
me personally,†said Nepalese native Dr. Tilak Shrestha. “But the whole
country gets this bad rap. That’s what we’d like to correct
Some also said the missing workers got a raw deal from Cinram, and that the stealing accusations aren’t true.
Earlier today those accusations were challenged by Nepalese leaders in town.
“You can’t accuse these people,†said Santosh Pokhrel. “Everyone
says Nepalese people stole and its not true. [Others are] just ripping
them off. [They are] actually stealing money from them because you are
taking advantage of these people.â€
Pokhrel has been a U.S. citizen for 12
years, and runs a gas station in Madison. The Nepal native came into
contact with some of the Cinram workers last week, and said both the
landlords and Cinram have tried to exploit his countrymen.
“We want to see them treated fairly,†Pokhrel said. “[The landlords]
need to take their word back. [The workers were] accused of stealing
furniture, and everyone knows its not true. You walk in that apartment
and you see how much that costs.â€
Nearly 240 workers got visa to work in Cinram Inc. a DVD company in Alabama under H-2B Work Program. When USA
agents and Nepal’ agent agreed to work to hire Nepalese workers from
Nepal, they recruited only those persons who pays $25,000.00 and their
(agents)intension was just provide visa and collect money from workers.
Even Nepal agent has earned Rs. 360000000.00 from workers. Who were in
road in yesterdays, they are propiter of Land, Appartments, Vehicles
etc in certain days. Neither Nepal governmen has taken any action
against them nor any others media has written about them. Agents in
Nepal have bought Bangala, Pajero, Car from that human smuggling
property. Even they have not paid government tax.
Nepal is very good and easy place for human smuglling for
international brokers. Actually, those people who were working in
Cinram, they have taught to leave there any time because they could not
earn such amount which they had paid to Nepal agents in 7 months workin
in CInram Inc, Alabama. It is not matter of losing and earning for
certain persons but it will be more difficult to get visa for real
Nepalese workes in coming days. Thanks.
and it begins - on Day 1 Trump will begin operations to deport millions of undocumented immigrants
From Trump “I will revoke TPS, and deport them back to their country.”
To Sajha admin
NOTE: The opinions
here represent the opinions of the individual posters, and not of Sajha.com.
It is not possible for sajha.com to monitor all the postings, since sajha.com merely seeks to provide a cyber location for discussing ideas and concerns related to Nepal and the Nepalis. Please send an email to admin@sajha.com using a valid email address
if you want any posting to be considered for deletion. Your request will be
handled on a one to one basis. Sajha.com is a service please don't abuse it.
- Thanks.